It’s hard to believe that with over 600 recipes and counting, I don’t have a recipe for Pico de Gallo yet! You’ll find it as an add-on of sorts in my Mexican recipes like my Chipotle Shrimp Tacos. But it’s way past time I shared with you my specific recipe for a good pico along with all my tips! There are a few things that make a Pico de Gallo authentic. And it’s just as simple as the ingredients you use. However, you’ll also find all my tips below for the tastiest Pico de Gallo based on what you have on hand or can buy at the store. First of all, we would have to talk about tomatoes, because what would this salsa be without tomatoes? Authentic recipes use Roma tomatoes or any de-seeded tomatoes of your choice. But one of my biggest flavor tips is to use grape cherry tomatoes. If it’s the height of summer, you’ll find the best tomatoes at the farmer’s market. However, you’ll find the Roma tomatoes from the store have the texture of styrofoam. And more often than not, they have little to no flavor at all. This just proves that being authentic is nice when you can, but not necessarily the best way to go for flavor. More often than not, you’ll find cherry tomatoes are your best store-bought option. Also when tomatoes aren’t in season, head over to my Easy Fire Roasted Blender Salsa which uses canned tomatoes.
Ingredients for this Pico de Gallo
Fresh tomatoes – As mentioned above, Roma tomatoes are normally used in authentic Pico de Gallo. However, in our area, the grape cherry tomatoes have been the most reliable for the best flavor. And it’s worth mentioning, that everyone always asks why my Pico de Gallo is so good. The big secret is all about starting with tomatoes that have the most flavor. So don’t worry too much about being authentic, and choose the best of what you have available. If you use ‘slicer’ type tomatoes, I would recommend de-seeding them before dicing them up. This is because they have way too much liquid for a good Pico de Gallo which is solved by removing the seeds. Roma tomatoes don’t have much in the way of seeds, so you can use them as is. Onion – White onion is traditionally used and has a great flavor in this fresh salsa. I’ve also used yellow and red onions as well when that’s what I had on hand. And they both work well too. Serrano or Jalapeno chilis – serrano chilis are the authentic choice, but they’re not always readily available for me. And since they’re a trip across town to another store, I most often use jalapenos. Another thing to consider is jalapenos aren’t as spicy as serrano chilis. So choose what works best for you because either chili flavor is fantastic! Fresh cilantro – freshly chopped cilantro adds tons of fresh flavor to this pico. And if you can find cilantro at the farmer’s market, definitely pick some up. Locally grown cilantro will blow you away with its incredible flavor! Lime juice – freshly squeezed is a must here because this recipe is all about fresh flavor. Sea salt – just a touch of salt is what you need to bring out all the salsa flavors.
Now let’s make this recipe step by step
Step 1: Assemble all your ingredients, wash, de-stem, etc.
If you choose cherry tomatoes, try for the grape cherry tomatoes as you see pictured above. The reason for this is they have less liquid and seeds than the round cherry tomatoes.
Step 2: Dice up the tomatoes of your choice into very small pieces. The smaller the dice the better the salsa texture will be.
Step 3: Mince the onion, jalapeno, and chop the cilantro, and juice the lime.
I like to use a juicer like the one pictured, but the handheld reamer works as well with a bit more effort.
Step 4: Add the minced onion, jalapeno, and cilantro to the cherry tomatoes, sea salt, and lime juice.
Step 5: Stir the Pico de Gallo together and season to taste with additional sea salt if needed.
Pico de Gallo tastes even better if the flavors are allowed to sit 10 minutes or so before serving. Refrigerate and use within 3-4 days.
This Pico de Gallo is part of my ‘build a bowl’ series
Chipotle Chicken (Chipotle Copycat) Cilantro Lime Rice Roasted Sweet Potatoes Easy Fajita Veggies The Best Guacamole Easy Fire Roasted Blender Salsa Instant Pot Queso (Vegan – Paleo – Dairy Free)
Choose as many of the above recipes as you’d like to mix and match and create a taco bowl or burrito bowl. You can also add all sorts of toppings like corn, black beans, grated cheese, and sour cream. I really hope you enjoy this easy Pico de Gallo recipe, it will add amazing fresh flavor to your Mexican dinners! And if you do get a chance to make it, I hope you’ll leave me a comment/rating below. I always love hearing from you here! Also for lots more Mexican inspired recipes, head over to the recipe index.
